Promoting the study of military history through the art of tabletop miniature wargaming

War Without Mercy: Liberty or Death in the American Revolution

.

.

by Mark Edward Lender and James Kirby Martin.

Hardback (6.5×9.5 inches). 296 pages. 2025.

While the book explains how Patriots and Loyalists waged a barbaric war against each other far from the organized battlefields, the more important aspect is why neighbors turned on each other during the American Revolution.

A Peckham study found that of the 1,331 land actions during the war, fewer than 100 involved regular armies battling each other. The rest were local militias, irregular forces, and ordinary families defending hearth and home (p28).

Of note, 238 of these were in NJ, 228 in NY, and 155 in SC (p29). Each receives their own chapter explaining how sympathy and tolerance diminished and the steady escalation of brutality.

Additional chapters explain the ruthless prosecution of genocide on the frontiers involving Indians (Native Americans) egged on by British agents.

The book contains eight color illustrations, five black and white maps, and six black and white illustrations. I knew about SC excesses from a previous book I reviewed and other books hinted at general burnings and killings, but this book covers a wider area. If you believe Mark Twain, history doesn’t repeat itself, but its sure rhymes. In a more modern era of today, this book can also serve as a warning how quickly name calling and altered images and propaganda videos can escalate to much worse.

Enjoyed it.

— Reviewed by Russ Lockwood

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share:

Article Categories
Recent Posts
Book Reviews

Soviet Rifleman vs German Infantryman: Combat 87

by Jacek Zabielski. Softcover (7.25×9.75 inches). 96 pages. 2026. Subtitle: Operation Bagration 1944 Operation Bagration caught the Germans out of position and the Soviets tore a strategic hole in the German front line during the summer of 1944. Not only did the Red Army have material and manpower superiority, it

Read More »
Book Reviews

American Civil War Siege Tactics: Elite 271

by Ron Field. Softcover (7.25×9.75 inches). 64 pages. 2026. This overview covers the usual ACW siege tactics, including saps, mining and tunneling, trenches, rifle pits, artillery bombardments, blockade, and storming. New to me is Professor Robert Grant’s Calcium Light — an oxygen-hydrogen combination that heats a block of calcium oxide,

Read More »
Book Reviews

Panther vs A30 Challenger: Duel 156

by Ivo van der Spoel. Softcover (7.25×9.75 inches). 80 pages. 2026. Subtitle: Operation Market Garden 1944 Although both designs began in 1941 to create an uparmored and upgunned tank, and both had considerable problems with early production, but the Germans proved far better at following through with mass production. The

Read More »
Secret Link

Contact an Individual

Please select the individual you wish to email.

Contact HMGS

Please only use this form if you can’t use one of the other Contact Us links.

Contact Outreach

Please only use this form to communicate with the Outreach volunteers.

Contact Membership support

Please only use this form to communicate with the Membership volunteers.

Contact Information Technology

Please only use this form to communicate with the Information Technology volunteers.

Contact Fall In! Exhibitors Manager

Please only use this form to communicate with the Fall In! volunteers.

Contact Fall In! Events Manager

Please only use this form to communicate with the Fall In! volunteers.

Contact Fall In!

Please only use this form to communicate with the Fall In! volunteers.

Contact Cold Wars Exhibitor Manager

Please only use this form to communicate with the Cold Wars volunteers.

Contact Cold Wars Events Manager

Please only use this form to communicate with the Cold Wars volunteers.

Contact Cold Wars

Please only use this form to communicate with the Cold Wars team.

Contact Historicon Exhibitors Manager

Please only use this form to communicate with the Historicon Exhibitors Manager.

Contact Historicon Events

Please only use this form to communicate with the Historicon Events Manager.

Contact Historicon

Please only use this form to communicate with the Historicon team.

Contact Convention Operations

Please only use this form to communicate with the Convention Operations volunteers.

Contact Marketing & Communications

Please only use this form to communicate with the Marketing & Communications volunteers.

Report a Website Issue