by Alastair Redman.
Hardback (6.4×9.5 inches). 272 pages. 2026.
Subtitle: The Warrior Who Redefined Western Scotland
The research about Lord Somerled seems there, but the prose and the formatting proved so distracting, I stopped reading on page 37. I skipped here and there throughout the rest of the book, but found the rest the same and gave up.
This seems like it was written by bulletpoint. Each chapter covers a particular topic, divided into ultrashort subheaded sections — usually two or three paragraphs long — better adapted for scrolling than reading. The prose has no flow. It’s just a bunch of related points jammed together. And given some of the melodramatic prose, I wondered if it was written by AI.
The book contains 19 black and white photos and nine black and white illustrations that seem generated by AI.
Maybe, to give the benefit of the doubt, it was meant to be read on the phone in short spurts and someone figured the multitude of parts could be published in book format.
Alas, this is not a biography, or at least a traditional biography. It has what information I suppose there is about Somerled and his era, but to my old-school way, it seems like a collection of 3×5-inch cards with notes without the prose to link them all and make sense of the man and his times.
— Reviewed by Russ Lockwood








